Kartini Clinic for Children and Families

Pediatric Eating Disorder Treatment Program

Get Help Now:
971-319-6800
  • Eating Disorder Treatment
    • Anorexia Nervosa
      • Signs & Symptoms: Anorexia
      • Causes and Triggers: Anorexia
      • Treatment: Anorexia
    • Bulimia Nervosa
      • Signs & Symptoms: Bulimia
      • Causes and Triggers: Bulimia
      • Treatment: Bulimia
    • Food Phobia
      • Signs & Symptoms: Food Phobia
      • Causes and Triggers: Food Phobia
      • Treatment: Food Phobia
    • ARFID
    • Treatment Overview
      • Inpatient
      • Partial Hospitalization (PHP)
      • Intensive Outpatient (IOP)
      • Virtual Intensive Outpatient (VIOP)
      • Outpatient
      • Cost of Treatment
  • Eating Disorder Resources
    • For Referring Providers
      • Hospitalization Criteria
      • Direct Referrals
    • Kartini School
    • For Parents & Guardians
      • Top Tips for Parents
      • Understanding Your Insurance
      • Talking to Your Employer
      • Insurance FAQ
      • Mental Health Parity Law
      • Family Housing Information
      • School During Treatment
      • Give Food a Chance
    • Research & Resources
    • Eating Disorder Treatment Videos
    • Glossary of Eating Disorder Terms
  • About Kartini Clinic
    • Why Kartini is Different
    • Will Treatment Work?
    • Our Staff
      • Julie O’Toole MD MPH
      • Naghmeh Moshtael MD
      • Shanna Greene
      • Morgan O’Toole
      • Megan Maples
      • Sherrill Gandsey RN
      • Leslie Weisner LMFT
      • Steve Nemirow
      • Amy Stauffer
      • Alex Garcia MA
      • Lisa Peacock LMFT
    • Contact Us
    • Careers at Kartini
  • Blog
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • YouTube

Physiology of Binge Eating and What Motivates Us

January 26, 2013 by Julie O'Toole

On the recommendation of Dr. Rod McClymont, of the Center for Eating and Dieting Disorders, Bathurst, Australia, I have been reading a new book, Animal Models of Eating Disorders (Humana Press 2013) edited by Nicole Avena.  The second chapter, by Mary M Boggiano Ph.D., stopped me in my tracks:  “Binge-Prone Versus Binge-Resistant Rats”.

Don’t laugh.  We are mammals; they are mammals.  We study rats to understand the physiology of cancer.  We study rats to understand the physiology of diabetes, of infectious diseases, of immunizations, of metabolic diseases.  And we study rats to understand the physiology of eating disorders.  Why?  Because eating disorders are not lifestyle choices or learned behaviors.  They are brain disorders, and although we differ from rats in important ways, the ways in which we are similar to them and to other mammals are vastly more numerous than not.

To bring you the “cliff notes” of the findings: the authors note that certain rats—those genetically programmed to be binge-prone will override all normal satiety cues and binge on large amounts of highly palatable foods (usually sweet and fat combinations such as Oreo cookies) if they are offered them, despite painful disincentives to doing so. Other rats, born binge-resistant, will self-limit the amount of such foods they consume. And this is not learned behavior either. The binge-prone rats will binge on their very first exposure to highly palatable foods and consistently thereafter, although intermittent introduction of these foods causes more bingeing than if they are exposed to such foods all the time.  I believe Psychology 101 tells us that intermittent reinforcement is the most powerful driver of behavior, and there you have it.

Binge eating in humans is commonly attributed to “cognitive dysregulation, irrational thinking, concern with body weight and image, etc” — otherwise known as gluttony, insecurity and lack of control.  But studies of rats, who presumably do not share these highly human concerns have shown that there is a more basic “reflexive” biology underlying binge eating, the author states — underscoring, in my view, the brain-based nature of eating disordered behavior.

Interestingly, the tendency to become fat was found to be independent of the tendency to binge.  The genetics of the two are quite distinct, although they can overlap in a few individuals.  It is important to note that not all people who are fat or obese — even very obese — binge eat.  And not all people who binge eat are fat. Again, the genetics for the two conditions are distinct.  

Incidentally, a genetic propensity to binge was only seen to emerge after puberty.  

The author made only one statement I would take issue with, and perhaps it was a typo:  she stated that the age of onset for “eating disorders” was after puberty.  I hope she meant that the onset of binge eating disorders (AN B/P; BN; BED) was after puberty, since we clearly see pre-pubertal patients with anorexia nervosa.

Famously, the Kartini meal plan does not include any highly palatable foods (desserts, sweets, etc) for the first year after diagnosis.  Dieting or starvation is known to exacerbate a tendency to binge on highly palatable foods when they are introduced.  This research would tell us that not everyone is equally prone to bingeing, but also that we can’t tell (yet) who carries the genetic predisposition for it.  Likewise, we cannot tell who carries the predisposition to become fat when exposed to a calorically rich environment.  Certainly those who design eating disorder food protocols should understand that even a morsel of highly palatable foods, and sometimes even just the smell can trigger relapse binge eating for some.

I am still digesting how this information will prove useful for those of us who design weight restoration plans for children with anorexia nervosa, and recovery plans for those with bulimia nervosa and other binge eating disorders.  It appears we may need to learn from our fellow mammals.  I’ll take it.  I just want the answer, from whatever corner of science it might arise.

Filed Under: Anorexia Nervosa, Binge Eating, Bulimia Nervosa, Eating Disorder Treatment, Eating Disorders

Recent Blog Posts

Are social media platforms making eating disorders in children worse?

January 10, 2023 By Morgan O'Toole-Smith

School During Eating Disorder Treatment? Not To Worry

October 13, 2022 By Morgan O'Toole-Smith

Online Reviews

September 23, 2021 By Morgan O'Toole-Smith

New to Treatment? Don’t Panic!

February 10, 2022 By Julie O'Toole

Kartini School: A Success Story

February 9, 2022 By Morgan O'Toole-Smith

Tips for Motivating Kids in School

January 19, 2021 By Morgan O'Toole-Smith

  • Eating Disorder Treatment
    • Anorexia Nervosa
      • Signs & Symptoms: Anorexia
      • Causes and Triggers: Anorexia
      • Treatment: Anorexia
    • Bulimia Nervosa
      • Signs & Symptoms: Bulimia
      • Causes and Triggers: Bulimia
      • Treatment: Bulimia
    • Food Phobia
      • Signs & Symptoms: Food Phobia
      • Causes and Triggers: Food Phobia
      • Treatment: Food Phobia
    • ARFID
    • Treatment Overview
      • Inpatient
      • Partial Hospitalization (PHP)
      • Virtual Intensive Outpatient (VIOP)
      • Intensive Outpatient (IOP)
      • Outpatient
      • Cost of Treatment
  • Eating Disorder Resources
    • For Referring Providers
      • Hospitalization Criteria
      • Direct Referrals
    • For Parents & Guardians
      • Top Tips for Parents
      • Understanding Your Insurance
      • Talking to Your Employer
      • Insurance FAQ
      • Mental Health Parity Law
      • Family Housing Information
      • School During Treatment
      • Give Food a Chance
    • Kartini School
    • Research & Resources
    • Treatment Videos
    • Glossary of Eating Disorder Terms
  • About Kartini Clinic
    • Why Kartini is Different
    • Will Treatment Work?
    • Our Staff
    • Contact Us
    • Careers at Kartini

TEST SEARCH

How to Recognize Eating Disorders in Boys

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PVgVmDIXqHc

Request Information

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

From Our Blog

Are social media platforms making eating disorders in children worse?

January 10, 2023

At least one school district in Seattle thinks so. Seattle Public Schools (SPS) has filed a suit in US DIstrict Court alleging that “defendants [social media platforms such as Facebook, TikTok, Instagram, YouTube, and Snapchat] affirmatively recommend and promote harmful content to youth, such as … Read Post...

School During Eating Disorder Treatment? Not To Worry

October 13, 2022

During the school year, families are sometimes hesitant to have their child enter treatment in the Partial Hospitalization Program (PHP) because they are worried about time away from school. The teachers at Kartini School understand your concern.  Often, our patients are super-conscientious … Read Post...

Online Reviews

September 23, 2021

This post is from Kartini Clinic CEO Morgan O'Toole.  Online reviews have become part of our everyday lives. Who hasn’t glanced at the star ratings when Googling a new hair salon or looking for a restaurant to try out? Most of the time, online reviews are just another useful data point when … Read Post...

New to Treatment? Don’t Panic!

February 10, 2022

Your child has been diagnosed with an eating disorder by one of the doctors at Kartini Clinic. Whether this is a restricting disorder with fear of fat, a bingeing and purging disorder or what we call ARFID (avoidant restrictive food intake disorder), it matters little.  What matters is that the … Read Post...

The Kartini Clinic Difference

At Kartini Clinic we practice only evidence-based, family-centered eating disorder treatment. Our program is a multi-disciplinary medical and psychiatric treatment model rather than an exclusively psychiatric approach to eating disorder treatment.  read more »

Eating Disorder Quick Links

Anorexia Nervosa
Bulimia Nervosa
Eating Disorder Treatment

Resource Quick Links

Referring Providers
Parent Resources
Understanding Insurance

Contact Us

Tel: (971) 319-6800
Fax: (503) 282-3409

help@kartiniclinic.com

3530 N Vancouver, Suite 400
Portland, OR 97227

Find us on Google Maps

Mon – Fri 9:00am – 5:00pm

Copyright © 2023 · Kartini Clinic · All Rights Reserved