Kartini Clinic for Children and Families

Pediatric Eating Disorder Treatment Program

Get Help Now:
971-319-6800
  • Eating Disorder Treatment
    • Anorexia Nervosa
      • Signs & Symptoms: Anorexia
      • Causes and Triggers: Anorexia
      • Treatment: Anorexia
    • Bulimia Nervosa
      • Signs & Symptoms: Bulimia
      • Causes and Triggers: Bulimia
      • Treatment: Bulimia
    • Food Phobia
      • Signs & Symptoms: Food Phobia
      • Causes and Triggers: Food Phobia
      • Treatment: Food Phobia
    • ARFID
    • Treatment Overview
      • Inpatient
      • Partial Hospitalization (PHP)
      • Intensive Outpatient (IOP)
      • Outpatient
      • Cost of Treatment
  • Eating Disorder Resources
    • For Referring Providers
      • Hospitalization Criteria
      • Direct Referrals
    • For Parents & Guardians
      • Top Tips for Parents
      • Understanding Your Insurance
      • Talking to Your Employer
      • Insurance FAQ
      • Mental Health Parity Law
      • Family Housing Information
      • School During Treatment
      • Give Food a Chance
    • Kartini School
    • Research & Resources
    • Eating Disorder Treatment Videos
    • Glossary of Eating Disorder Terms
  • About Kartini Clinic
    • Why Kartini is Different
    • Will Treatment Work?
    • Our Staff
      • Julie O’Toole MD MPH
      • Naghmeh Moshtael MD
      • Shanna Greene
      • Morgan O’Toole
      • Megan Maples
      • Sherrill Gandsey RN
      • Leslie Weisner LMFT
      • Steve Nemirow
      • Amy Stauffer
      • Alex Garcia MA
      • Lisa Peacock LMFT
    • Contact Us
    • Careers at Kartini
  • Blog
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • YouTube

Why Weight Restoration in Eating Disorder Treatment Must Come First

December 29, 2016 by Julie O'Toole

This post was originally published on February 13, 2012.

I (among others) have recently been challenged by Laura Collins to get the message out that weight restoration is critical to psychological recovery in anorexia nervosa. Some authority, Laura says, must declare definitively that psychological recovery is tied to weight restoration.

Some authority… okay… but who?

Since the late 1990’s the AAP (American Academy of Pediatrics) has issued guidelines for hospitalization (after all, a serious intervention) based on medical parameters and weight gain. They are a bit dated now, but still extremely useful in our quest to (a) keep children with anorexia nervosa safe and (b) force insurance carriers to cover such inpatient restoration and the induction of re-feeding. The sad thing is that many, many, MANY therapists and doctors ignore these guidelines and continue to treat patients in an outpatient setting with insufficient weight restoration, even though a patient would clearly meet AAP guidelines for hospitalization, e.g. orthostatic or bradycardic or less than 75% of their former weight, or (in the case of very young children) not growing along their former trajectory and being stunted.

What to do about this? AED (Academy for Eating Disorders) has issued their own guidelines for medical restoration, which are helpful in that they have a target readership of more than just pediatricians (the target readership of the AAP guidelines). Kartini Clinic received a grant several years ago to produce and distribute Spotting the Tiger, with its strong emphasis on weight restoration, to all pediatricians, pediatric nurse practitioners and family doctors in Oregon, Idaho and Washington. The result: a resounding silence. Not many watched this DVD, as far as I can tell- those physicians and nurse practitioners who have called me for help over the years have never reported opening it or having read it. And although I know that I am not “the authority” Laura seeks, I have written extensively about the critical role of weight restoration in full remission/recovery in my book Give Food A Chance and in my blogs.

So why the heck do people seem so impervious to the message that without weight restoration you get nothing? And I do mean nothing: no physical recovery AND no psychological recovery. Remember: psychological recovery is about the brain. The brain is an organ of the body; like all other organs it needs fuel to replace broken or used-up cells, and for functioning cells to communicate with each other. Starvation is as bad for children and for any other living thing. This takes no great leap of intellect: you can’t become psychologically normal in a state of malnutrition. You don’t (or shouldn’t) need access to all “latest science” to know this. What happens when you starve any other mammal? Think about it.

Why the resistance to this simple message?  

I postulate that it is yet another leftover from the days when the treatment of anorexia nervosa was the sole purvue of psychiatry. Even today, the adolescent psychiatric unit at our own hospital makes little attempt to re-feed patients who come to them for other reasons but who also have an eating disorder.  They’re “not set up for it” they tell me, and they “don’t believe that food should be forced” because they are not the “food police” and because they believe in motivational interventions that are precluded when the patient is not “vested in their own recovery.” They often tell us that unless the patient is “motivated” to get well, no intervention is going to be meaningful. The excuse offered is that “ideal body weight is controversial” and can’t be determined accurately anyway. In keeping with this (mistaken) belief, psychiatrists- and others- chronically underestimate a child’s goal weight.  

Folks, it’s just not that hard to set a biologically meaningful goal weight for a child or adolescent; a little complex perhaps – like much of medicine – but certainly not too difficult or impossible.

In this country, as horribly broken as our system of medical care/insurance/access is, we are still largely able to vote with our feet. If your doctor or therapist doesn’t understand how critical complete weight restoration is to your child’s full recovery, find another one who does. My friend Charlotte from the UK tells me that “voting with your feet” is simply not possible in the system they have over there, and I can only believe her. With sorrow.

And you know what? In the US, voting with your feet is not the sole purvue of the educated elite. In this country even folks of simpler background are on the web every day, searching Craigslist, communicating on Facebook, networking socially, shopping for deals, selling on Ebay, and they can also search for care for their children on sites like NEDA, or EDReferral.com.  Families from all over can read everything written on approaches to their child’s illness: so get informed, get powerful, and don’t accept “what’s always been done” for no other reason than because it’s always been done or because the provider who does it this way happens to be conveniently located near you. Start a discussion thread relevant to your life, and above all read and share discussion groups/resources already out there such F.E.A.S.T., Kartini’s blog, Sarah Ravin’s blog, Carrie Arnold’s blog, Xtra normal’s films by Bushesbre, and many more. Most of these blogs will have a list of recommended sites for further reading.

That great leveler, the Web, is on your side.

Filed Under: Anorexia Nervosa, Eating Disorder Treatment, Eating Disorders

Recent Blog Posts

New to Treatment? Don’t Panic!

February 10, 2022 By Julie O'Toole

Kartini School: A Success Story

February 9, 2022 By Morgan O'Toole-Smith

Online Reviews

September 23, 2021 By Morgan O'Toole-Smith

Tips for Motivating Kids in School

January 19, 2021 By Morgan O'Toole-Smith

Dr. O’Toole to retire at the end of 2020.

December 16, 2020 By Morgan O'Toole-Smith

Breaking Science News: The Latest Genetic Study of Anorexia Nervosa

July 18, 2019 By Julie O'Toole

  • Eating Disorder Treatment
    • Anorexia Nervosa
      • Signs & Symptoms: Anorexia
      • Causes and Triggers: Anorexia
      • Treatment: Anorexia
    • Bulimia Nervosa
      • Signs & Symptoms: Bulimia
      • Causes and Triggers: Bulimia
      • Treatment: Bulimia
    • Food Phobia
      • Signs & Symptoms: Food Phobia
      • Causes and Triggers: Food Phobia
      • Treatment: Food Phobia
    • ARFID
    • Treatment Overview
      • Inpatient
      • Partial Hospitalization (PHP)
      • Intensive Outpatient (IOP)
      • Outpatient
      • Cost of Treatment
  • Eating Disorder Resources
    • For Referring Providers
      • Hospitalization Criteria
      • Direct Referrals
    • For Parents & Guardians
      • Top Tips for Parents
      • Understanding Your Insurance
      • Talking to Your Employer
      • Insurance FAQ
      • Mental Health Parity Law
      • Family Housing Information
      • School During Treatment
      • Give Food a Chance
    • Kartini School
    • Research & Resources
    • Treatment Videos
    • Glossary of Eating Disorder Terms
  • About Kartini Clinic
    • Why Kartini is Different
    • Will Treatment Work?
    • Our Staff
    • Contact Us
    • Careers at Kartini

Request Information

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

From Our Blog

New to Treatment? Don’t Panic!

February 10, 2022

Your child has been diagnosed with an eating disorder by one of the doctors at Kartini Clinic. Whether this is a restricting disorder with fear of fat, a bingeing and purging disorder or what we call ARFID (avoidant restrictive food intake disorder), it matters little.  What matters is that the … Read Post...

Kartini School: A Success Story

February 9, 2022

[Ed. note: This is one in a series of guest blogs by our Kartini School administrator, Mary Gunesch. With schools returning to at least partial in-person instruction we thought it a good time to focus on this subject.]  When a student begins treatment at Kartini Clinic, we reach out to their … Read Post...

Online Reviews

September 23, 2021

This post is from Kartini Clinic CEO Morgan O'Toole.  Online reviews have become part of our everyday lives. Who hasn’t glanced at the star ratings when Googling a new hair salon or looking for a restaurant to try out? Most of the time, online reviews are just another useful data point when … Read Post...

The Kartini Clinic Difference

At Kartini Clinic we practice only evidence-based, family-centered eating disorder treatment. Our program is a multi-disciplinary medical and psychiatric treatment model rather than an exclusively psychiatric approach to eating disorder treatment.  read more »

Eating Disorder Quick Links

Anorexia Nervosa
Bulimia Nervosa
Eating Disorder Treatment

Resource Quick Links

Referring Providers
Parent Resources
Understanding Insurance

Contact Us

Tel: (971) 319-6800
Fax: (503) 282-3409

help@kartiniclinic.com

3530 N Vancouver, Suite 400
Portland, OR 97227

Find us on Google Maps

Mon – Fri 9:00am – 5:00pm

Copyright © 2022 · Kartini Clinic · All Rights Reserved